1920-1929
1920 Kent State Golden Flashes MAC
1921 Fresno State Bulldogs Mountain West
1921 San Diego State Aztecs Mountain West
1922 BYU Cougars Independent
1924 Ball State Cardinals MAC
1924 Georgia Southern Eagles Sun Belt
1925 Texas Tech Red Raiders Big 12
1926 Miami (FL) Hurricanes ACC
1928 Appalachian State Mountaineers Sun Belt
1930-1939
1931 Louisiana-Monroe Indians Sun Belt
1932 East Carolina Pirates American
1933 Boise State Broncos Mountain West
1940-1949
1946 Houston Cougars American
1947 Florida State Seminoles ACC
1950-1959
1951 Louisiana–Monroe Warhawks Sun Belt
1955 Air Force Falcons Mountain West
1960-1969
1968 UNLV Rebels Mountain West
1970-1979
1973 Liberty Flames Independent
1979 UCF Knights American
1990-1999
1991 UAB Blazers C-USA
1997 South Florida Bulls American
2000-2009
2001 Florida Atlantic Owls C-USA
2002 FIU Panthers C-USA
2003 Coastal Carolina Chanticleers Sun Belt
2009 Old Dominion Monarchs C-USA
2009 South Alabama Jaguars Sun Belt
2010-2019
2010 Georgia State Panthers Sun Belt
2011 UTSA Roadrunners C-USA
2013 Charlotte 49ers C-USA